Pushing into the late evening of this Tuesday night past, the Internet suddenly got a little more stupid. Discouraged by some comments left on a website about his 2010 book purge, Harlan Ellison finally thumbed his nose at the ‘Net and switched off the pops and hisses of his antediluvian dial-up modem for the last time. He’s done with it, with you and with us. He bought the ticket, took the ride and hopped out of the spinning teacup when it started teetering a little too precariously upon its own axis as the ridecar, he realized, was being dangerously overspun by a gaggle of waterheaded asshats who somehow managed to take control of world. So he’s out of here. Gone. Absent without leave from all of the flippant inanity that continues to consume the entirety of Web content from ass to mouth like some sort of twisted, fiber-optic Ouroboros. Good job, Internet. You just climbed another rung on the Great Ladder of Ineptitude and murdered a Titan along the way. Thanks. Thanks a lot.
I know what it was on the site in question (which I refuse to reference) that crawled under Harlan’s skin to skitter about his endoskeleton and finally push him over the edge, and I agree with him – to a point. Some say the man has built a career out of being an obstinate and irate blatherskite, but the kind of person who says things like this tends to be the sort who spends too little time with books and too much with thesauruses. Talentless hacks (to use a less polite but more succinct description), the failed and the failing always look upon the mighty and despair, not out of jealousy or frustration but out of resentment and loathing for that which they will never be. And they know it – and the more they know it, the more vitriolic their contempt grows and the greater their hate becomes. Every writer knows this, and every writer out there busily keyfucking their typewriters and cut-and-pasting their manuscripts knows in their guts that they are better and worse than some other writer out there doing the same. There is always someone you’ll never best and there’s always someone who will never best you. The difference between someone like Harlan and everyone else is that he’s earned the right to shout hate at the heart of a world gone drunk and stupid from reality television and talk show book clubs. He’s earned it not because he’s built his career out of being a loudmouthed braggart, but because he’s built his career out of doing the work.
He’s done the work and he’s sold the work while aggressively and willfully spitting in the eyes of an industry filled with vipers and leeches, who smile as they sink their teeth into the soft flesh of weaker writers too afraid of rejection to lop the heads off the murderous little bastards. The sad truth is that if more writers were like Ellison – even with half the talent, but all of the drive – the world might not be governed by the whimsical fancy of the functionally illiterate. Harlan’s “Pay The Writer” speech from Dreams With Sharp Teeth recently passed 400,000 views on YouTube – an ironic twist considering the content of the speech and its method of distribution – and still, no one gets the point. Writers are such insecure, neurotic bundles of broken dreams and phantasmagoric hope that the world is bursting at the seams with wannabes all scrambling to freely donate their souls to every slick-backed producer or priggish publisher who winks at them and offers them ‘exposure’. Websites offering publicity in exchange for the right to freely publish submissions fill the Internet with no shortage of hopeful scribblers looking for their big break. “I’m published, Ma!” and now click on over to a site called Unicorn Moonbow Press International (or something equally inane) to read my stuff! No, I’m not getting paid – but I’m published!
The same mentality pervades every level of the industry, and it’s why brilliant and successful writers still have to hold down day jobs to pay the mortgage and feed the kids. Well that, and too few people bother to read challenging books. The same industry that is loathe to pay daring writers of dangerous visions a sum they might live on is more than happy to shovel paperbacked horse crap onto bookstore shelves, because the shitstank books simply sell better than the hard stuff. It’s the way of the world, and it’s only getting worse as the chigger of the Internet crawls deeper under our skin to continue its parasitic draining of our collective intelligence.
But none of this is news. It’s an old story, but one that only grows more depressing with time. The Internet, for all its glittering promises of equality and brotherhood, of leveling the playing field for everyone and creating the world’s first true meritocracy, has amounted to little more than a collection of nut-shot videos and Stupid Human Tricks. It provides safe haven for liars and thieves, dilutes our consciousness and bends our reality. Hiding under the mask of some inverse morality where the slogan “Information is free” gets people out from under the weight of a crushing cognitive dissonance that comes from knowing that stealing someone else’s work is wrong. Books, movies, music, games – everything is up for grabs on the World Wide Web, and only suckers actually pay for anything, right?
But again, this isn’t news. Harlan has long crusaded against the digital theft of his work, and he’s won more times than he’s lost. He’s been called many names and been the unfortunate recipient of a lot of misplaced rage, but he’s always stood his ground and given as good as he’s got. No, none of this is what pushed one of the greatest literary voices of our age off of the Internet. What finally did it, I’m afraid, is the same thing that threatens anyone who puts his soul out there on the page for all the world to see and mock and shred. It haunts each and every one of us, and we defend against it all our lives. Eventually, it takes its toll.
I’m not going to quote the comments or cast light on insecurities that plague every single creative professional working in the world today, and I’m certainly not going to risk embarrassing Harlan by exposing my thoughts on exactly what pushed him over the edge and made him push the big red Abort button on his Internet presence. What I will say is simple and direct, and meant as solely for Harlan as it is for anyone else who dares to actually live:
Fighting against an uncaring world is what we do. We do it because no one else will, or can, or will do as good of a job. It’s who we are, even when we don’t want to be. We’re misanthropic because we love harder and stronger than anyone will ever understand. We see the dirt and grime of this world with keen, sharp vision that stings our souls because we know just how beautiful the filth really is because it’s part of something real, something true – undiluted and sharp and nasty and brittle and broken…and sublime. We ply our trade in artifice because the real truth of things can be excised only from the malignant tumors of our fiction. We are a cancerous lesion on the soul of humanity that must be cut out, burned off and nuked into oblivion because that’s what we’re here for. We hold up a mirror and reflect the hideous reality people would rather not see – but that they must, if they are ever to become something more. Something better. Something…like us.
That’s it. I’m done, and let the comments flow forth from your poisoned pens and chemo-keyboards ridiculing my hubris and mocking my confessions. I’m ready for it. It’s what I’m here for. It’s what I do. Kinda like Harlan, only half of a half of a quarter of a tenth as good…but I’m working on it. Give me time.
And Harlan? Get back up. Your story isn’t over yet, and you know damn well that you’re the only menacing old bastard who gets to finish it – not them. Never them.

Don't you wanna be cool, too?
13 Responses to “From The Internet, With Hate”



I am so sorry to hear that Mr. Ellison has left the ‘net, but even sadder to discover that he was upset by some troll. I adore him and his work. And as far as his being “all mean and stuff,” he did me a great favor on my birthday one year at the request of a mutual friend when he called me to briefly discuss a short story that I had intended to present at a SF/F con for his critique. That was way above and beyond the call of duty, and we had a lovely talk about all sorts of things. I think he is one of the most talented writers of our generation, and I think that far, far lesser lights are getting all the attention (and the culture is worse off for it). I hope that he feels much better once he forgets about this online melee and goes back to the lower-tech life. I’ve often considered the question of whether I’m really better off spending so much time tilting at the windmills on the ‘net when I could be contemplating butterflies. Good luck and happy times to Harlan Ellison and his wife Susan and their household!
Thanks for a great article. This needed to be said and I’m glad someone said it.
The World Wide Web, like a bookstore only more so, is what you make of it. There’s smart stuff, stupid stuff, hard stuff, easy stuff, fun stuff, boring stuff. There is, in fact, whatever you want. Just like in a bookstore. Only for larger values of “you”.
half of a half of a quarter of a tenth as good
I think you might be overestimating yourself there.
For all your fine words and noble suffering, the brutal fact is that even if the world has become a cesspool of imbeciles, a full cesspool of imbeciles is MORE IMPORTANT TO PRESERVE than an eyedropper of brilliance. So fuck you, fuck Harlan, fuck all writers who say fuck you to readers. Bleh.
I do hope that makes sense at least to you, somehow, for some reason.
Otherwise, your comment would be a perfect waste of time and space.
Holy crap, I thought he’d DIED!! O.O
If he’s just gafiating from the ‘net, so what? Everyone has the perfect right to hermit up every so often to detox from idiot exposure, including Harlan Ellison.
We hold up a mirror and reflect the hideous reality people would rather not see – but that they must, if they are ever to become something more. Something better. Something…like us.
Oh, honey, no. Dreary pastiches of Harlan Ellison that indulge in hubris while missing the actual point by a country mile aren’t exactly Fighting the Good Fight, are they? Ellison left because he’s a control freak whose experience of the Internet is limited to the tiny window of his hilariously outmoded message board and its coterie of sycophants. Apparently, he’s all put out that sites are referring to this as “Harlan Ellison’s Book Purge,” instead of “Harlan Ellison’s Wife’s Book Purge, Which Harlan Ellison Is Grudgingly Allowing,” which is patently absurd.
How ironic that someone who always railed against uninformed comments should never have bothered to understand the very medium he claims to be disgusted with, and that prompted more actual writing than anything else he’s done in a decade. All in all, an embarrassing performance, as is this blog entry.
Ellison needs the Internet FAR more than it needs him. He’ll be back…this isn’t the first time he’s said goodbye. Once he realizes that with no books on the shelves, the Internet is the only way for him to make money, he’ll come crawling back with the usual back-pedaling that he’s so good at.
What was said that was so horrendous that Ellison quit the intarwebs for good? Because he’s said some pretty terrible things in his day, so I’m hoping it’s really, really worthy. But I doubt very much that it is.
All this drama queenish door slamming over THAT? Anyone else find it ironic that Ellison, who prides himself on being nasty and vicious towards anyone who pisses him off, flounces off for good over a few comments about his book sale?
Grow a thicker skin, and quit being such a hypocrite.
You’ve got a little cognitive dissonance going on here, friend. Maybe it’s Stockholm Syndrome. This some serious internet haterade coming from someone who is publishing his novel online for free.
Frankly, the world has always been run by water-headed asshats and to write and rage against it is to suffer their poo-slings and arrows. A little shitstain on the lapel is a badge of honor. Are you the minority? Yes. Haven’t you always been?
And you know, I’m actually surprised that Harlan can still command such vigorous championing at this point. As a long time fan/apologist, he lost me for good when he groped Connie Willis. Fucking unacceptable.
While the man has penned some classic science fiction gems, I find it hard to understand what his lack of internet presence robs us of. So why the (admittedly entertaining) sturm und drang? It’s not like his body of work, which is by far the best thing about him, has suddenly vanished from every bookshelf on earth.
You can’t use “asshat,” the main poster already did. Sorry, I know you thought it was cool.
Ellison’s lack of Internet presence is a BLESSING, and should be celebrated as such. The fewer big-mouthed, bellowing chowderheads we have eating bandwidth, the better off we are.
He and his work are always there for the nostalgists. Most of them are hanging out on his site…hoping for his return…